Current:Home > StocksIowa court affirms hate crime conviction of man who left anti-gay notes at homes with rainbow flags-InfoLens
Iowa court affirms hate crime conviction of man who left anti-gay notes at homes with rainbow flags
View Date:2024-12-23 14:30:26
The Iowa Supreme Court affirmed the hate crime conviction Friday of a man who posted hand-written notes at homes with rainbow flags and emblems, urging them to “burn that gay flag.”
The majority rejected the claim by Robert Clark Geddes that his conviction for trespassing as a hate crime violated his free speech rights. But a dissenting justice said a hate crime conviction wasn’t appropriate since it wasn’t clear if the people displaying the symbols were actually associated with the LGBTQ+ community.
As the court noted, the rainbow flag has come to symbolize support for LGBTQ+ rights. The majority said the state statute in question does not criminalize speech, but rather conduct with a specific intent — trespassing because the property owners or residents had associated themselves with a protected class.
“The individuals’ display of the LGBTQ+ flag or flag decal on their own properties was an exercise of First Amendment rights; the defendant’s surreptitious entry onto those properties to post his harassing notes was not,” the court said.
Handwritten notes turned up in June of 2021 taped to the front doors of five renters and homeowners in the town of Boone who displayed rainbow flags or decals. All said, “burn that gay flag.” One contained additional anti-gay slurs. The recipients told police they found the notes “alarming, annoying, and/or threatening,” according to the decision.
Based on surveillance video from some of the homes, police identified Geddes as the man who left the notes, and he acknowledged posting them. He was charged with five counts of trespassing as a hate crime. He was later convicted and was sentenced to up to two years of probation.
On appeal, Geddes argued prosecutors failed to prove he targeted persons who were LGBTQ+ or had a connection with them. He said his conviction therefore violated his free speech rights.
Iowa’s hate crime law requires that the victim was targeted because of their “race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, political affiliation, sex, sexual orientation, age, or disability,” or because of their ”association with” people in those categories.
In his dissent, Justice Matthew McDermott said there was no evidence in the record that the recipients of Geddes’ notes were members of the LGBTQ+ community or whether he believed they were, nor whether any of the residents had an “association with” an actual person in those protected classes. He noted that the Legislature chose the words “association with” rather than “solidarity with” when it wrote the hate crime law.
“As a symbol, a flag doesn’t independently create or express actual association with particular persons,” McDermott wrote, adding that, “Not everyone who displays a pirate flag is associated with actual pirates.”
Geddes’s attorney Ashley Stewart said they were disappointed in the decision.
“We should all be concerned with protecting the free marketplace of ideas under the First Amendment even if the ideas are minority opinions,” Stewart wrote in an email. “Iowa’s hate crime statute requires the victim be associated with a targeted group. We agree with the dissent that the mere display of a flag on a home does not meet the criteria.”
Jane Kirtley, a First Amendment expert at the University of Minnesota, said the dissenting justice may have a valid point. When hate crimes are so tied to expression, she said, the particular facts of the case matter. She agreed that there might not be enough facts in the record to establish whether Geddes’ actions violated the hate crimes law, given its use of the vague term “association with.”
“Words matter,” Kirtley said in an interview. “Legislatures can write with greater precision. Judges are reluctant to read things into ambiguous language, and rightly so.”
veryGood! (367)
Related
- Tesla Cybertruck modifications upgrade EV to a sci-fi police vehicle
- Steal Hearts With Michael Kors' Valentine’s Day Collection Full of Chic Finds That’ll Woo Her Away
- LSU football coach Brian Kelly releases bald eagle, treated by the university, back into the wild
- Target pulls Black History Month book that misidentified 3 civil rights icons
- Justice Department says jail conditions in Georgia’s Fulton County violate detainee rights
- With opioid deaths soaring, Biden administration will widen access to methadone
- Shop Amazon’s Epic Baby Sale & Stock Up on Highly-Rated Essentials from Medela, Dr. Brown's & More
- What is code-switching? Why Black Americans say they can't be themselves at work
- Why Cynthia Erivo Needed Prosthetic Ears for Wicked
- Groundhog Day 2024 full video: Watch Punxsutawney Phil as he looks for his shadow
Ranking
- Horoscopes Today, November 12, 2024
- Judge dismisses case against Michigan man accused of threatening Biden, Harris
- Gypsy Rose Blanchard's 'fans' have turned on her. Experts aren't surprised.
- Sofía Vergara Steps Out With Surgeon Justin Saliman for Dinner in L.A.
- Gigi Hadid and Bradley Cooper Prove They're Going Strong With Twinning Looks on NYC Date
- Report: Feds investigating WWE founder Vince McMahon sex-trafficking allegations
- Arkansas parole board chair was fired from police department for lying about sex with minor
- Did Staten Island Chuck see his shadow? New York's groundhog declares early spring in 2024
Recommendation
-
Disease could kill most of the ‘ohi‘a forests on Hawaii’s Big Island within 20 years
-
Carl Weathers, linebacker-turned-actor who starred in 'Rocky' movies, dies at 76
-
Joe Rogan signs new multiyear Spotify deal that allows him to stream on other services
-
A scrappy football startup, or 'the college Bishop Sycamore'?
-
Maryland man wanted after 'extensive collection' of 3D-printed ghost guns found at his home
-
Desmond Gumbs juggles boxing deals, Suge Knight project while coaching Lincoln football
-
US bolsters defenses around Jordan base as it readies strikes in response to drone attack
-
NPR's Student Podcast Challenge is back – with a fourth-grade edition!